Idea
How to stop caring what people think: Stoicism for approval-seekers
Stoic tools for approval-seeking: what Epictetus and Marcus Aurelius said about other people's opinions, the spotlight effect, and five exercises to try this week.

Stoicism does not ask you to stop caring about people; it asks you to stop treating their opinion of you as the verdict on your worth. Other people's judgements are outside your control, so the Stoic move is to take what is useful from them as information, drop the rest, and judge yourself by whether you acted well. Small, deliberate exposures to looking foolish train this faster than reasoning alone.
Key takeaways
- Epictetus told students who wanted to improve to be content to be thought foolish about outward things.
- Marcus Aurelius was puzzled that people love themselves most yet value others' opinion of them above their own.
- Research on the spotlight effect suggests people notice your slips far less than you assume.
- Criticism can be useful information about an action without being a ruling on who you are.
- Choosing in advance whose judgement you take seriously makes everyone else's easier to let pass.
Priya rewrites a two-line message to her team four times before sending it. Then she watches for replies, reads one colleague’s “ok” as cold, and spends the evening wondering whether she sounded pushy. Nothing bad has happened. Yet the imagined opinion of five people has taken up most of her day.
The Stoics wrote a surprising amount about this. They were public people: one ran a school, one advised an emperor, one was the emperor. Being judged was part of their lives, and they built practical tools for not being run by it. Below are those tools, a piece of modern research that backs one of them up, and a handful of exercises.
Caring about people is not the same as caring about their verdict
The common advice to “stop caring what people think” sounds like a recipe for coldness. The Stoics did not mean that. Marcus Aurelius repeatedly reminds himself that humans are made for one another, and in Meditations 3.4 he describes the ideal mind as “simple and benevolent, and such as befits a social animal” (George Long’s translation).
What they separated was the person from the person’s opinion of you. Your friend’s wellbeing matters. Whether your friend thought your joke at dinner was a bit much is a passing judgement in someone else’s head, and it is not yours to control. That split is the same one Epictetus builds his whole teaching on, explored in our guide to the dichotomy of control. For the wider picture of how these ideas fit together, start with Stoicism for everyday life.
A practical test helps. When someone’s opinion bothers you, ask two questions. Is there information here I can use to act better? And is the sting about my action, or about my worth? Feedback on a report is information. The feeling that you are now “the one who sends bad reports” is a verdict you added yourself.
Marcus Aurelius’s puzzle about self-love
Late in the Meditations, Marcus writes that he has often wondered how every person loves themselves more than anyone else, yet “sets less value on his own opinion of himself than on the opinion of others” (Meditations 12.4). He goes on to say that we have far more respect for what our neighbours will think of us than for what we think of ourselves.
He did not solve the puzzle so much as name it, and naming it is useful. Approval-seeking often feels like humility. Seen through Marcus’s eyes, it is closer to an odd ranking: everyone else’s passing impression placed above your own considered view of how you are living. It is also what makes a refusal so hard; how to say no to a friend without feeling guilty turns that into words you can actually send.
He also noticed the time it costs. In Meditations 3.4 he warns against wasting the rest of your life in thoughts about others, listing the exact loop Priya is stuck in: what is that person doing, saying, thinking. He adds a fair qualifier. Thinking about others is fine when it serves some common good. Replaying what a colleague might privately think of your email rarely does.
Epictetus: be content to look foolish
Epictetus is blunter. “If you would improve, be content to be thought foolish and dull with regard to externals,” he tells his students (Enchiridion 13, Higginson’s translation).
The point is that growth and looking good pull in different directions. Think of Gareth, who at forty-two signs up for an evening language class. The fastest way to learn is to speak badly, out loud, in front of strangers. The way to look competent is to stay quiet. He cannot fully have both, and Epictetus would tell him to choose speaking.
He also had a disarming answer to gossip. If someone tells you a person has been speaking badly of you, he says, do not defend yourself; reply that they must not have known your other faults, “else he would not have mentioned these alone” (Enchiridion 33). It is a joke, but a wise one. It concedes that you are imperfect, which removes the threat, and it refuses to make the critic’s view your problem.
And for decisions you have thought through, he is clear: if you are acting rightly, “why fear those who wrongly censure you?” (Enchiridion 35).
What the research adds: you are less visible than you feel
The Stoics argued from reason. Modern psychology adds a reason to believe that most of the judging you fear is not happening in the first place.
In a set of studies led by Thomas Gilovich at Cornell, students were asked to wear a T-shirt with a potentially embarrassing image into a room of peers. They overestimated how many people would be able to recall what was on the shirt. In another study, people in group discussions overestimated how much their own good and bad comments stood out to others (Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 2000). The researchers called this the spotlight effect, and suggested that we start from our own vivid experience of a moment and then fail to adjust enough for the fact that others are busy with theirs.
Consider Leah, who knocks over a cup of coffee at the start of a meeting. For her it is the defining event of the morning. For most people in the room it is a few seconds of mopping between thoughts about their own agendas. The study does not say nobody notices anything; it says we consistently overestimate how much.
Five exercises for loosening the grip
- Pick your judges (10 minutes, once). Write down two or three people whose opinion of your work or character you genuinely want to earn, and why. When anyone else’s reaction bothers you, check: is this person on the list? If not, let the opinion pass as weather.
- Practise small foolishness (once a week). Following Enchiridion 13, do one minor thing you avoid out of image concern: ask the obvious question, admit you have not read the book, sing quietly in the car with the window down. Note how long anyone remembers it.
- Use the Epictetus reply (whenever criticism reaches you second-hand). Say, at least to yourself, “they clearly haven’t seen my other faults.” Then decide whether the criticism contains anything worth fixing.
- Catch the 3.4 loop (as it happens). When you notice yourself rehearsing what someone thinks of you, label it: “guessing someone’s mind.” Then turn to one action that is yours today.
- Write the facts, then the story (2 minutes). After an awkward moment, write one sentence of what happened and one of what you feared it meant. Leah’s might read: “I spilled coffee. I feared they think I’m a mess.” Seeing the second line on paper usually shrinks it.
Make it easier: start with exercise 1 alone for a week. Make it harder: choose a slightly larger act for exercise 2, such as sharing an unfinished idea in a meeting before you have polished it.
When fear of judgement is more than a habit
Everyone feels self-conscious sometimes. If fear of being judged stops you speaking at work, eating in front of others or leaving the house, or if it comes with panic, that can be social anxiety, which responds well to treatment. A GP or therapist is a better next step than philosophy alone; our guide to understanding anxiety explains what help looks like.
For the everyday version, the Stoic tools are enough to begin. Marcus put the goal well in Meditations 4.18: “How much trouble he avoids who does not look to see what his neighbor says or does or thinks, but only to what he does himself.” You will still notice other people’s opinions. The work is to stop letting them have the final word.
The wise move
This week, do one small thing you have avoided for fear of looking silly, such as asking the basic question in a meeting. Afterwards, write down what you feared people thought and what actually happened.
Questions people ask
Is wanting people to like you a weakness?
No. Humans are social, and Marcus Aurelius described people as made to work with one another. The problem the Stoics saw was handing other people the power to decide whether you are at peace, not the wish to be liked.
How long does it take to care less about other people's opinions?
There is no study that puts a timeline on it. In practice, people tend to notice the change as a shorter recovery time: the sting of a comment fades in an hour instead of a week. That shift is a better measure than never feeling it at all.
What should I do when the criticism is actually fair?
Use it. Fix the specific thing and thank the person if that fits. The Stoic point is to act on fair criticism without accepting the extra story that one mistake says something final about you.
Sources
- The Enchiridion, by Epictetus (translated by Thomas Wentworth Higginson) — Project Gutenberg, 2014
- Thoughts of Marcus Aurelius Antoninus (Meditations, translated by George Long) — Project Gutenberg, 2005
- The spotlight effect in social judgment: an egocentric bias in estimates of the salience of one's own actions and appearance (Gilovich, Medvec & Savitsky) — Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 2000
Read how we work in our editorial standards.


