Practice

Stoic evening review questions: what Seneca asked, and a 5-minute routine

Stoic evening review questions taken from Seneca and the Pythagorean verses Epictetus quoted, turned into a five-minute routine, with examples and a fair tone.

Illustration: a bedside table at night with a small lamp just switched off, a closed notebook and reading glasses on it, moonlight on the curtain

Ask three to five short questions about the day just gone: what did I do well, where did I fall short, what did I leave undone, and what will I do differently next time. The first set comes from Seneca's teacher Sextius, the second from verses Epictetus attributed to Pythagoras. Answer them in writing in about five minutes, in the tone of a fair coach, and end by letting the day go.

Key takeaways

  • Seneca reviewed his day after the lamp was taken away, then forgave himself out loud before naming what to change.
  • Epictetus wanted the old verses kept ready for use, not recited, and mocked a courtier who used them to audit his flattery.
  • Specific answers about one moment help more than broad verdicts about your character.
  • Self-compassion after a mistake was linked to more effort to improve, not less, in a set of four experiments.

The day ends, and most of it slips away unexamined. The awkward thing you said in a meeting, the kindness you managed when you were tired, the call you meant to make: by morning they have blurred into “Tuesday”. The Stoics thought a few honest questions at night could turn each day into something you learn from, without turning bedtime into a trial.

Our guide to Stoicism for everyday life introduces the evening review as one of seven practices. This page goes into the questions themselves: where they come from, which ones to use, a five-minute routine, and how to keep the tone fair.

Where the questions come from

The best-known description is in Seneca’s On Anger, Book III, chapter 36. He credits the habit to the philosopher Sextius, who asked himself at the end of each day: “What bad habit of yours have you cured to-day? what vice have you checked? in what respect are you better?” (Seneca, Of Anger III.36, Stewart translation).

Seneca then describes his own version. When the lamp has been taken out and his wife, “who knows my habit”, has stopped talking, he goes over everything he said and did. “I conceal nothing from myself, and omit nothing,” he writes. What he finds is strikingly ordinary: he argued too hotly with people who were not ready to listen, and he rebuked someone more bluntly than the man could bear. Before naming these, he says to himself, “I pardon you this time: see that you never do that anymore.”

A second set of questions reaches us through Epictetus. Discussing how to keep useful principles at hand, he quotes these lines, which elsewhere he calls a saying of Pythagoras (Epictetus, Discourses III.10, Long translation):

“What’s done amiss, what done, what left undone; / From first to last examine all, and then / Blame what is wrong, in what is right rejoice.”

Epictetus adds that these verses should be kept so that we “may use them, not that we may utter them aloud”. And in Book IV he mocks a courtier who runs the same nightly check, but asks where he failed at flattery (Epictetus, Discourses IV.6, Long translation). The point is sharp: the questions are only as good as the standard you measure yourself against.

A set of questions to choose from

You do not need all of these every night. Pick three, and keep them for a few weeks so the answers become comparable.

QuestionWhere it comes fromA useful answer looks like
What did I do well today?“In what is right rejoice” (Pythagorean verses)One specific action, not “I was fine”
Where did I fall short?“What’s done amiss”One moment, with a time or place
What did I leave undone?“What left undone”A task or a word you meant to give
Which habit did I hold back today?Sextius, via SenecaThe urge, and what you did instead
In what am I better than last week?Sextius, via SenecaA small change you can actually see
What will I do differently next time?Seneca’s notes to himselfA plan for the same situation
Was the standard I used today worth having?Epictetus on the courtierAn occasional check, monthly at most

The five-minute routine

Do this at the same point every evening: after the dishes, when you sit on the edge of the bed, or on the bus home after a late shift.

  1. Run the day in order (1 minute). Seneca passed “the whole day in review”. Start from waking and move forward quickly, like flicking through photos. Stop on the two or three moments that still carry a charge.
  2. Answer your three questions in writing (2 minutes). One line each. Name the moment, not your character: “At the 3pm call I interrupted Sam twice,” not “I am rude.”
  3. Turn one answer into a next step (1 minute). Pick the most useful line and make it concrete: “Tomorrow, in the planning meeting, I will let Sam finish before I speak.”
  4. Pardon and close (1 minute). Borrow Seneca’s formula in your own words: “That is forgiven; next time, this.” Close the notebook. The review is over, and so is the day.

If you also want to notice how you are spending your time, the memento mori practice for beginners has a two-minute evening review built on that question. For a longer look back once a week, see the Sunday reset.

Three evenings, three reviews

Hannah, a ward nurse, after a twelve-hour shift. Done well: stayed with a frightened patient’s daughter for five minutes she did not really have. Fell short: snapped at a student nurse over a missing chart. Next time: when she feels rushed, say “give me two minutes” instead of a sharp reply. She writes it on the bus and does not think about the shift again.

Kwame, father of a fifteen-year-old. Left undone: he meant to ask how his son’s football trial went and forgot. Habit held back: he did not check his work email at dinner. Next time: ask about the trial at breakfast, first thing. The review takes four minutes, and the most useful line is the one about something he did not do.

Lucy, retired, volunteering at a food bank. Done well: showed a new volunteer how the stock room works. Better than last week: she said no to an extra shift she did not have energy for, without over-explaining. Her notebook is mostly good news, which the Pythagorean verses would count as doing it right.

Keeping it from becoming self-punishment

Seneca ends his own review by noting that a good person welcomes correction. He does not describe lying awake ashamed. His verdict comes with a pardon attached.

Modern research points the same way. In four experiments, people encouraged to treat a recent mistake or weakness with self-compassion were more motivated to make amends and improve, and in one study spent longer studying after failing a test, than people in comparison conditions (Breines & Chen, 2012). Being kind about the slip did not make them complacent.

The way you phrase the answers matters too. A review of research on repetitive thinking found that abstract, evaluative dwelling on upsetting events (“why am I always like this?”) tended to go with worse outcomes, while concrete thinking was linked to useful planning (Watkins, 2008). That is why the routine asks for a moment and a time, not a judgment of your whole self.

Warning signs that the review has turned sour: it takes longer each night, you dread it, the “fell short” column fills while “done well” stays empty, or you lie awake replaying it. If so, cut to one question, “What went well?”, for a week. If low mood or self-criticism is following you through the day as well, talk to a GP or a therapist. If you ever feel unsafe, use our crisis help page to find someone to call now.

Small, regular, and finished

The evening review works because it ends. Seneca closed his with a pardon and went to sleep, and he described that sleep as calm and sound. Pick three questions, give them five minutes, and let tonight’s answers be the last word on today.

The wise move

Tonight, write the date and three headings on one page: 'Done well', 'Fell short', 'Next time'. Fill one line under each, then write 'Pardoned for today' at the bottom and close the notebook.

Questions people ask

Should the evening review be written or done in my head?

Seneca seems to have done it silently, in the dark. Writing is slower but keeps the review short and concrete, and lets you see patterns across a month. A good compromise is writing on weekdays and a mental run-through when you are away.

What if nothing went wrong today?

Then the review is short. Answer the 'done well' question properly and look for what you left undone, which is easy to miss on a pleasant day. The Pythagorean verses treat rejoicing in what went right as part of the job.

Can I do the review with a partner?

Some couples share one 'done well' and one 'next time' each over the washing-up. Keep the 'fell short' part for yourself, so the conversation stays about your own actions rather than each other's.

Sources

  1. Of Anger (De Ira), Book III, by Seneca (translated by Aubrey Stewart, 1900) — Wikisource, 1900
  2. The Discourses of Epictetus, Book 3 (translated by George Long) — Standard Ebooks
  3. The Discourses of Epictetus, Book 4 (translated by George Long) — Standard Ebooks
  4. Self-compassion increases self-improvement motivation — Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin (Breines & Chen), 2012
  5. Constructive and unconstructive repetitive thought — Psychological Bulletin (Watkins), 2008

Read how we work in our editorial standards.