Practice

Journaling prompts for overthinking, grouped by what you are stuck on

Journaling prompts for overthinking, sorted by situation: a looming event, a replayed conversation, a stuck decision, what-ifs. Plus what the research says.

Illustration: a writing desk by a window in the evening, an open notebook with a pen, a small hourglass and a mug in warm lamp light

Pick the prompt that matches the loop you are in, write by hand for ten to fifteen minutes, and finish with one next step or one sentence that closes the page. Good starting prompts are 'What exactly am I afraid will happen?', 'What do I actually know, and what am I guessing?' and 'What is the smallest thing I could do about this tomorrow?'

Key takeaways

  • Research on writing about feelings shows small benefits on average, and some reviews find none for low mood, so treat prompts as a tool, not a cure.
  • Specific prompts and several sessions tend to do better than a single vague one.
  • Writing down worries and checking later whether they came true can show how often the mind predicts the worst.
  • If a page leaves you more wound up than when you started, change prompts or stop for the day.

You open a notebook because someone said journaling helps with overthinking. You write “I can’t stop thinking about it”, and then the same thought in different words for a page and a half. Twenty minutes later you have a sore hand and the same knot in your stomach.

A blank page often just gives the loop more room. What helps is a question that points the thinking somewhere: towards facts, a prediction you can test, or a next step. Below are prompts sorted by the kind of loop you are in, along with an honest look at what writing can and cannot do.

What the research says about writing through worry

Most studies look at expressive writing, where people write about their deepest thoughts and feelings for a few sessions. A 2023 meta-analysis of 31 randomised trials with about 4,000 participants found a small but significant benefit for depression, anxiety and stress symptoms in people without a clinical diagnosis, and the benefit tended to appear some time after the writing rather than straight away (Guo, 2023). Small is the right word: the average effect was modest.

An earlier meta-analysis of 39 trials, focused on depressive symptoms, found no significant long-term effect from brief, self-directed expressive writing. Effects were larger, though, when people wrote over more sessions and when the topic was more specific (Reinhold et al., 2018). That is one reason the prompts below are narrow rather than “write how you feel”.

Writing can also help in the moment. In experiments at the University of Chicago, students who spent about ten minutes writing about their fears before a high-pressure test did better than those who did not, with the clearest gains in students who were usually anxious about tests (ScienceDaily summary of Ramirez & Beilock, 2011). Those were small studies about exams, so the finding is a lead, not a law.

Two other techniques use writing in a more structured way. In one small study, 29 adults with generalised anxiety disorder logged their worries for ten days and later recorded whether they came true. About 91% of the predictions did not, and people who saw more of their worries fail to happen tended to improve more (LaFreniere & Newman, 2020). And worry postponement, parking worries in a written list for a set time each day, reduced worry in a trial of people with generalised anxiety (Krzikalla et al., 2024). How to run a daily worry slot is covered in how to stop overthinking at night.

How to use a prompt

  1. Choose one prompt, not a list. Match it to the loop you are actually in.
  2. Write by hand for ten to fifteen minutes. Set a timer so the page has an ending.
  3. Write facts and specifics, with names, dates and numbers where you can.
  4. Finish with a closer: one next step, one prediction to check, or one sentence that sums up where you have landed.

The closer is the part most people skip, and it is what turns writing into something other than rehearsal.

Prompts by situation

You are stuck onTry writingFinish with
Something coming up (a test, a hard meeting)“What exactly am I afraid will happen? What would I do if it did?”One thing to prepare tonight
A conversation you keep replaying“What was actually said, word for word? What am I adding?”One question you could ask them, or a decision to let it go
A decision you cannot make“If a friend had these two options, what would I tell them? What am I waiting to find out?”A date to decide by
A string of what-ifs“What is the worst, the best and the most likely outcome?”A prediction to check, with a date
Something you cannot control“Which part of this is mine to act on, and which part is not?”One action on the part that is yours
Everything at once“List every worry in one line each. Which one is loudest?”The loudest one, and its smallest next step

When something is coming up

Anticipation is where many loops start. Sana has a performance review on Thursday and has been writing imaginary conversations in her head since Monday. Her prompt: “What exactly am I afraid will happen?” Her answer turns out to be one sentence: that her manager will mention the missed deadline in March. Underneath, she writes what she would say if it comes up. The worry has not gone, but it now has a shape and a reply.

When you keep replaying a conversation

Replays tend to grow. A neutral comment becomes a hint, then a judgement. Writing the actual words down, in quotation marks, separates what was said from what you have built around it. Dev wrote out a colleague’s comment, “Interesting approach”, and next to it the three meanings he had been cycling through. Seeing them on paper, he noticed he had no evidence for any of them and decided to ask. If the replay is about something you got wrong at work, how to stop ruminating about a mistake at work has a fuller method.

When you cannot decide

Overthinking a decision often means waiting for a certainty that is not coming. The friend question helps because advice to others is usually clearer than advice to ourselves. The second question, “What am I waiting to find out?”, shows whether there is real information missing or just discomfort. If something is missing, write how you will find it. If not, write a date to decide by.

When the what-ifs multiply

This is where the worry log earns its place. Write the worry as a prediction with a date: “The landlord will refuse to fix the boiler before winter.” Then check. Ewan, who worries about his health, wrote down every new fear for a month. Looking back, almost none had come to anything, which gave him something solid to set against the next one.

When writing makes things worse

Writing is not neutral for everyone. If you finish a page feeling more agitated, notice which prompt did it. Open-ended writing about painful material can stir things up, especially late in the evening. Switch to a factual prompt, write earlier in the day, or put the pen down and do something with your hands for a while. A week of entries that all say the same thing is also a signal: the prompt has stopped working and the loop has moved onto paper.

When overthinking needs more than a notebook

Overthinking during a stressful patch is common. It is worth getting help if the worry is hard to control on most days, covers many areas of life, and comes with restlessness, tense muscles, tiredness or poor sleep. The US National Institute of Mental Health describes these as signs of generalised anxiety disorder and notes that it is treatable, often with talking therapy, medication or both (NIMH). Our guide to understanding anxiety explains how everyday worry differs from an anxiety disorder, and a GP or psychologist is a good first step.

If your thoughts turn to harming yourself, do not wait: contact your local emergency number or use our crisis help page to find a line you can call now.

For an ordinary loop on an ordinary evening, one well-chosen question and fifteen minutes is often enough to get it out of your head and onto the page, where it is easier to see clearly.

The wise move

Tonight, write one current worry at the top of a page as a prediction ('I think X will happen by Friday'), put a reminder in your phone for Friday evening, and then write underneath what actually happened.

Questions people ask

Is it better to journal on paper or on my phone?

Either can work. Paper keeps you away from notifications and tends to slow the writing down, which helps with racing thoughts. If you only ever have your phone with you, a notes app is better than not writing at all.

Should I reread what I wrote while overthinking?

Rereading your predictions to check whether they came true is useful. Rereading long, emotional entries over and over can turn into another loop, so keep those for occasional reflection rather than daily review.

How is this different from a gratitude journal?

A gratitude journal points attention at what went well. These prompts work on the worry itself: naming it, testing it and turning it into a step. Some people do both, at different times of day.

Sources

  1. The delayed, durable effect of expressive writing on depression, anxiety and stress: a meta-analytic review of studies with long-term follow-ups (Guo), abstract — British Journal of Clinical Psychology (abstract via NYU Information for Practice), 2023
  2. Effects of expressive writing on depressive symptoms: a meta-analysis (Reinhold, Bürkner & Holling) — Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice (author copy), 2018
  3. Writing about worries eases anxiety and improves test performance (summary of Ramirez & Beilock, Science) — ScienceDaily / University of Chicago, 2011
  4. Exposing worry's deceit: percentage of untrue worries in generalized anxiety disorder treatment (LaFreniere & Newman) — Behavior Therapy (Penn State research portal), 2020
  5. Worry Postponement From the Metacognitive Perspective: A Randomized Waitlist-Controlled Trial (Krzikalla et al.) — Clinical Psychology in Europe, 2024
  6. Generalized Anxiety Disorder: When Worry Gets Out of Control — National Institute of Mental Health

This article is general information, not medical advice. Talk to a doctor or qualified professional about your own situation. Read how we work in our editorial standards.